She was from Queens, not France

In partnership with

Startups who switch to Intercom can save up to $12,000/year

Startups who read beehiiv can receive a 90% discount on Intercom's AI-first customer service platform, plus Fin—the #1 AI agent for customer service—free for a full year.

That's like having a full-time human support agent at no cost.

What’s included?

• 6 Advanced Seats

• Fin Copilot for free

• 300 Fin Resolutions per month

Who’s eligible?

Intercom’s program is for high-growth, high-potential companies that are:

• Up to series A (including A)

• Currently not an Intercom customer

• Up to 15 employees

Apply now

Hey there,

What if everything you believed about your favorite luxury brands was completely made up?

Here's something wild: Estée Lauder sounds like French royalty, right? Sophisticated. European. Aristocratic.

Her real name was Josephine Esther Mentzer. She was born in Queens, New York, to Hungarian and Czech immigrant parents. Nothing French about her.

But "Estée Lauder" commanded premium prices in a way "Josephine Mentzer" never could. That invented European identity helped build a $150 billion beauty empire.

The craziest part? She wasn't the only one. Some of the world's most "prestigious" brands are built entirely on fabricated European backstories created by immigrant entrepreneurs who understood one truth: People pay more for perceived prestige than actual quality.

Estée Lauder's invented French aristocracy

Picture this: You're a Jewish girl from Queens in the 1930s. You want to sell beauty products to wealthy Manhattan socialites.

But there's a problem. Your name is Josephine Mentzer. That doesn't exactly scream luxury and sophistication.

So Josephine did something genius. She changed her name to "Estée Lauder" and started telling people she learned her beauty secrets from European aristocrats.

None of it was true.

Her "ancient European formulas"? Created by her uncle, a chemist in Queens. Her "aristocratic training"? She learned by selling face creams at beauty salons. Her "sophisticated heritage"? Pure fabrication.

But the invented backstory worked like magic.

Wealthy women paid premium prices for products from the "European-trained" Estée Lauder. The same creams would have been dismissed as "cheap immigrant products" under her real name.

By creating a fictional prestige story, Lauder transformed identical products into luxury goods. Same formulas. Different perception. Massive price difference.

Today, Estée Lauder Companies is worth over $150 billion, owns 25+ prestige beauty brands, and generates $16 billion annually. All built on a completely invented European identity.

Häagen-Dazs' fake Danish heritage

Here's one that'll blow your mind: Häagen-Dazs sounds Scandinavian, right? Danish, maybe? Swedish?

It's completely made up. The name means absolutely nothing in any language.

Reuben Mattus was a Jewish immigrant from Poland who sold ice cream from a horse-drawn cart in the Bronx. His ice cream was good, but nobody wanted to pay premium prices for "Bronx ice cream from a street vendor."

In 1960, Mattus invented the name "Häagen-Dazs" specifically because it sounded Danish and sophisticated. He even put a map of Denmark on the packaging.

Why Denmark? Because Denmark had protected Jewish refugees during World War II, and Mattus wanted to honor that. But also because European names commanded higher prices than American ones.

The ice cream didn't change. Just the name.

Suddenly, the same ice cream from the same Bronx factory became "imported European luxury." Customers happily paid double the price for this "authentic Danish" product that had never been to Denmark.

Häagen-Dazs now generates over $2 billion annually globally. Built entirely on a fabricated Scandinavian identity created in the Bronx.

Corona's invented Mexican beach mystique

Corona beer loves to position itself as the authentic Mexican beach experience. The marketing shows pristine beaches, laid-back surfers, and tropical paradise.

Here's the truth: Corona was created in Mexico City by Spanish immigrant entrepreneurs trying to compete against German beer brands dominating Mexico.

The beach association? Completely invented by American marketers in the 1980s.

Corona was actually a cheap, working-class beer in Mexico. Nothing premium about it. Nothing particularly associated with beaches or resorts.

But when Corona entered the American market, marketers realized something: Americans would pay premium prices for "authentic Mexican beach beer" even though no such thing existed in Mexico.

They invented the entire beach lifestyle positioning. Added lime wedges (not traditional in Mexico). Created advertising around tropical escapes. Positioned it as the vacation beer.

Same beer. Different story. Triple the price.

Corona became America's top imported beer, generating over $7 billion annually for parent company Constellation Brands. All from a fabricated beach identity that Mexicans would barely recognize.

Why fake prestige beats real quality

Here's what these three understood: Customers don't buy products. They buy stories, identities, and status.

Lauder's creams weren't better than competitors. They just had a better story.

Mattus' ice cream wasn't from Denmark. But the Danish mystique justified premium pricing.

Corona wasn't beach beer in Mexico. But Americans wanted to believe it was.

Perception isn't just reality. Perception IS the product.

The psychology behind invented prestige

Status signaling matters more than ingredients
People want to signal sophistication, worldliness, and good taste. A product with European heritage does that better than one from Queens or the Bronx.

Foreign mystique justifies premium pricing
Identical products command different prices based purely on perceived origin. European = luxury. American = ordinary. This pricing psychology is completely emotional, not rational.

Customers buy the lifestyle, not the item
Corona doesn't sell beer. They sell vacation mindsets. Estée Lauder doesn't sell cream. She sold European sophistication. The product is almost irrelevant.

The invented prestige playbook

These entrepreneurs followed the same pattern:

Identify what prestige looks like in your category
Lauder recognized European beauty = luxury. Mattus understood Scandinavian = quality. Corona's marketers knew Mexican beaches = escape.

Create a compelling fictional backstory
Doesn't have to be true. Just has to feel authentic and aspirational. The story sells, not the facts.

Commit completely to the narrative
Häagen-Dazs put Danish maps on packaging. Estée Lauder spoke about her European training constantly. Corona built entire marketing campaigns around beaches. No half-measures.

Let customers tell themselves the story
Once the narrative exists, customers convince themselves it's real. They want to believe in the prestige they're buying.

Why this still works today

Look around. How many "artisanal" products are made in factories? How many "ancient recipes" were created last year? How many "European-inspired" brands have never left America?

Invented prestige is everywhere because it works.

Customers consistently pay more for perceived heritage, authenticity, and sophistication than for actual quality differences.

A soap becomes luxury when the story changes. Coffee becomes premium when the origin sounds exotic. Clothing becomes fashion when the designer name sounds European.

The product matters less than the story you tell about it.

These three billionaires proved that your background doesn't determine your brand positioning. Your narrative does.

Lauder wasn't from France. She became French in customers' minds.

Mattus wasn't from Denmark. His ice cream became Danish through pure storytelling.

Corona wasn't beach beer. It became the beach experience through marketing.

What story are you telling about your product?

Because here's the truth most entrepreneurs miss: Competing on quality is hard. Everyone can improve quality. Everyone can match features. Everyone can lower prices.

But no one can compete with a great story. No one can copy a compelling narrative. No one can replicate the mystique you create.

The businesses that command premium prices don't have better products. They have better stories about their products.

What fictional prestige could you create?