- Income Ivy
- Posts
- 300 investors said no to this idea
300 investors said no to this idea
The billion-dollar mistakes hiding in rejection letters
Hey there,
Let's talk about the most expensive "no" in business history. In 1962, a young animator was told his cartoon mouse "lacked imagination" and wouldn't appeal to audiences. That animator was Walt Disney, and the mouse was Mickey.
Today, Disney is worth over $200 billion. The executives who rejected Disney's vision? Their companies are footnotes in business history.
Every entrepreneur faces rejection. But the difference between those who build empires and those who give up isn't talent, connections, or even luck. It's what they do with the word "no."
Here are three rejection stories that became billion-dollar lessons in persistence, pivoting, and proving doubters wrong.
Walt Disney Gets Fired for Lack of Imagination
In 1919, Walt Disney was fired from a Kansas City newspaper for "lacking imagination and having no good ideas." Multiple investors rejected his early animation concepts, calling cartoons a "passing fad" with no commercial future.
When Disney pitched Mickey Mouse to MGM in 1928, executives laughed him out of the room. "A cartoon about a mouse? Who would want to watch that?" They suggested he focus on something "more realistic."
What this teaches entrepreneurs:
Disney didn't waste time trying to convince the skeptics. Instead, he found different distribution channels, eventually partnering with smaller studios willing to take risks. When facing rejection, look for alternative pathways instead of beating down the same door. Sometimes the best customers aren't the obvious ones.
Disney's persistence paid off. Mickey Mouse became a cultural phenomenon, leading to theme parks, merchandise, movies, and a media empire that generates over $80 billion annually. The "mouse that lacked imagination" became one of the most valuable intellectual properties in history.
How Pandora's Founder Survived 300 Rejections
Between 2000 and 2004, Pandora founder Tim Westergren pitched his "Music Genome Project" to over 300 venture capital firms. The rejections were brutal:
"Streaming music will never work over the internet."
"People don't want computers picking their music."
"This is a solution looking for a problem."
Westergren was so broke during this period that he couldn't pay his team for two years. Fifty employees worked without salaries, believing in the vision when no investor would.
The practical approach:
Westergren treated each rejection as free market research. He refined his pitch, improved the technology, and built proof of concept while others said it was impossible. Turn every "no" into data: Why did they reject it? What concerns came up repeatedly? Use this feedback to strengthen your offering.
The company that "would never work" was eventually valued at over $3 billion. Those 300 VCs who said "no" watched from the sidelines as streaming music revolutionized an entire industry.
Airbnb's Journey from Cereal Boxes to Global Empire
In 2008, Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia were so broke they were selling novelty cereal boxes to pay rent. Their idea for Airbnb was rejected by virtually every investor they approached.
Fred Wilson from Union Square Ventures called it "the worst idea we've ever heard." Another investor said, "Strangers will never stay in each other's homes. It's unsafe, weird, and has no scalable business model."
Even Paul Graham from Y Combinator was skeptical, telling them, "People actually use this?" when Airbnb was barely generating $200 per week.
What worked for them:
Instead of pivoting away from their core concept, Chesky and Gebbia doubled down on solving real user problems. They personally visited hosts, took professional photos, and improved the user experience one customer at a time. When investors don't believe in your vision, focus obsessively on making customers successful.
They turned rejections into motivation, famously creating Obama O's and Cap'n McCain's cereal boxes during the 2008 election to fund their startup when investors wouldn't. Today, Airbnb is worth over $75 billion and has fundamentally changed how people travel.
Lessons That Actually Matter for Your Business
Timing isn't everything, but it's something
Many "obvious" ideas seem impossible until they're inevitable. The internet, smartphones, and social media all faced similar skepticism before transforming society. Don't let timing discourage you from pursuing transformative ideas.
Build your tribe first
Disney found small studios, Pandora found patient employees, and Airbnb found individual hosts. Sometimes the best strategy is finding people who share your vision rather than convincing those who don't. Build momentum with believers before tackling skeptics.
Make rejection work for you
Each "no" provides valuable data about market perceptions, competitive concerns, and areas for improvement. Smart entrepreneurs treat rejections as free consulting sessions that reveal exactly what needs to be addressed.
Get creative with funding
When traditional funding sources say no, creative entrepreneurs find other ways. Disney's smaller studios, Pandora's patient team, and Airbnb's cereal boxes all demonstrate that resourcefulness beats traditional capital.
Why Rejection Might Actually Help You
Here's what most entrepreneurs miss: rejection is often a competitive advantage in disguise. If everyone immediately understood and funded your idea, you'd face massive competition from day one.
The ideas that get rejected often represent the biggest opportunities because they require vision, persistence, and belief that most people lack. By the time your concept becomes "obvious" to everyone else, you'll have years of head start.
The next time someone says your idea won't work, remember that you're in excellent company. Some of the world's most valuable businesses started with investors, experts, and critics saying "no."
Your job isn't to avoid rejection. It's to prove them wrong.
What rejection has motivated you most? Hit reply and share how a "no" led to something better in your business journey.